Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell
February 3rd, 2010Since President Obama announced that he planned to repeal “Don’t ask. Don’t tell.” during his State of the Union address, there has been considerable hubub from all the usual players (and even some unusual ones!). If you have been paying attention to politicians and political bloggers, you know that everyone has an opinion about the United States’ military policy of requiring soldiers to maintain a veil of silence about their sexual orientation, provided that orientation is something other than “straight”. Here is mine.
I have yet to hear a convincing argument in favor of “Don’t ask. Don’t tell.” Admittedly, I don’t know all that much about military morale, which is what Senator Jon Kyl was citing as his line of defense yesterday on NPR. BUT, I find it hard to believe that a military that can convince its members that killing is alright cannot convince its members that a woman loving another woman is not. Unfortunately, Senator Kyl did not elaborate on how being gay is bad for morale.
Another argument in favor of “Don’t ask. Don’t tell.” that I have heard is that being gay is immoral. I know that there are religions that teach that being gay is a sin. But don’t those same religions also teach that murder is a sin? If we can gray the line, religiously, between murder and killing (as we do with our military pursuits), certainly we can blur the line between being gay and loving another human being, if only to achieve our military goals.
At the end of the day, I am always impressed with what I perceive to be a raw fear of change by many people on this policy. The same people that are supporting it now were vehemently against its institution in 1993.
Do people really believe deep in their hearts that allowing lesbians to serve openly in the military is a bad thing. Surely they understand that there are already lesbians serving. Don’t they? All this policy would do is allow lesbians to tell their friends about it.